Direct-to-Garment Printing Vs Screen Printing: Deciding Which Is Best For You

Direct-to-Garment Printing Vs Screen Printing

In the world of custom apparel, there is an epic battle for dominance brewing: Direct-to-Garment Printing Vs Screen Printing. Both methods offer unique benefits and are suited for different purposes. Whether you’re a business owner looking to create branded merchandise or an individual seeking custom clothing, it’s crucial to understand the key differences and pros and cons of each method to make an informed decision. So, let’s dive into the world of DTG and Screen printing and discover which one suits your needs best.

Direct-to-Garment Printing vs Screen Printing

Direct-to-Garment Printing (DTG)

DTG printing is a modern, innovative, and versatile printing method. Here’s a breakdown of its characteristics:


  1. Unlimited Colors: DTG allows for the printing of intricate designs with an unlimited range of colors. This is a game-changer when you want photorealistic images or designs with many hues.
  2. Detailed and Complex Designs: DTG excels at reproducing fine details, making it perfect for intricate or complex designs.
  3. Ideal for Small Orders: If you need a few shirts or custom pieces, DTG is cost-effective and suitable because it has no setup costs.
  4. Soft to the Touch: DTG ink is water-based and soaks into the fabric, resulting in a soft and comfortable feel. Your printed design won’t crack or peel.
  5. Quick Turnaround: DTG printing has a faster turnaround time compared to screen printing, making it suitable for last-minute orders.


  1. Not Ideal for Large Orders: As the printing process is slower for each garment, it’s less cost-effective for large orders.
  2. Limited on Dark Garments: DTG works best on light-colored fabrics. While it can be used on dark materials, the results may not be as vibrant.
  3. Investment: Purchasing DTG-printed t shirts can be a great way to get low quantities of custom shirts. But the amount of ink consumed per shirt requires a larger price tag, making it a less viable option (again, especially for larger orders).

Screen Printing

Screen printing is a classic and time-tested method that has been used for decades. Let’s explore its characteristics:


  1. Cost-Effective for Large Orders: Screen printing becomes more cost-effective as the order size increases. It’s the go-to choice for bulk orders.
  2. Great for Simple Designs: If you have a design with minimal colors, screen printing can produce sharp and bold results.
  3. Long-Lasting Prints: Screen prints can withstand wear and tear, making them suitable for work uniforms and heavy-duty apparel.
  4. Versatility: This method can be used on various fabric types, including dark-colored garments.


  1. Limited Color Range: Traditional screen printing limits the number of colors in your design. Each color requires a separate screen, which increases costs and complexity for multicolored designs.
  2. Not Suitable for Small Orders: Screen printing is not cost-effective for small orders due to setup costs. It’s better suited for bulk printing.
  3. Lack of Detail: Fine details and complex designs may not be as clear with screen printing.
  4. Ink Thickness: The ink in screen printing sits on top of the fabric, potentially resulting in a heavier, less comfortable feel.

The Print Plug’s Expertise:

At The Print Plug in Nampa, Idaho, we understand that each project is unique. Our team of experts is here to guide you in choosing the best printing method for your specific needs. With over 10 years experience in the industry, 100+ 5-star Google reviews, and back-to-back wins for ‘Best Custom T-Shirt Shop’ in Nampa, we’re the trusted choice for quality and service.

Direct-to-Garment Printing Vs Screen Printing

So, Which Is the Right Choice for You?

The decision between DTG and screen printing depends on your specific requirements:

  • Choose DTG if you need a small batch of custom shirts with intricate, colorful designs, and you’re working with light-colored garments. DTG is also suitable for quick turnarounds and a soft, comfortable feel.
  • Opt for Screen Printing if you have a bulk order of simple designs with minimal colors, especially if you’re working with dark fabrics and need long-lasting prints.

Remember that at The Print Plug, we offer both DTG and screen printing services, so you don’t have to choose just one. You can explore the advantages of both methods to meet your unique needs.

Contact The Print Plug for Your Custom Printing Needs!

Ready to make a decision, but still unsure about the best printing method for your project? Don’t hesitate to reach out to our expert team at The Print Plug. You can call us at 986-777-9466 for a personalized consultation. We’re here to help you create the perfect custom apparel that matches your vision and budget. Let’s make your ideas come to life!

In the world of custom printing, your options are endless, and with The Print Plug, your creations are bound only by your imagination. Contact us today and let’s embark on a printing journey that sets you apart from the rest.

The Print Plug – The Proof is In The Printing

624 16th Ave S

Nampa, ID 83651


Check out our Reviews on Our Google Business Profile

Follow Us On Instagram